Perfect divisions of a cake
نویسندگان
چکیده
The problem studied in this paper arises from a simple practical problem: how to divide a cake among the children attending a birthday p a r t y i n s u c h a way that each c hild gets the same amount o f c a k e and (perhaps more important to them) the same amount of icing. Let S be a convex set contained in the (xx y)-plane. In mathematical terms, a c a k e C with base S is a solid containing all the points with coordinates (xx y z) such that (xx y 0) 2 S and 0 z h, h > 00 h is called the height o f C. The exposed area of C consists of the boundary of C minus S, i.e. the base of a cake is not considered to be exposed. A cake will be called a polygonal cake if S is a convex polygon. A division of a cake C into k parts by a series of vertical cuts is said to be perfect if each p a r t i s c o n vex and has the same volume and the same exposed area of S. Our birthday c a k e problem can be stated as follows: given a cake C , d o e s i t have a perfect partitioning into k pieces? If a cake has such a partitioning, we will also say that C can be cut perfectly. A c a k e whose base is a square can be cut perfectly into three pieces as follows: take a n y three points x, y and z that divide the perimeter of its base into three pieces of the same length. Now make v ertical cuts along the line segments connecting these points to the center of the base of the cakee see Figure 1. Perfect partitionings of cakes in which t h e v ertical cuts are all along line segments concurrent a t a p o i n t p are called radial perfect partitionings. Notice that for any k > 0, any circular cake C has a radial perfect partitioning into k pieces. This motivates the following deenition. A c a k e C is called graceful if, for every k, there is a perfect radial partitioning of C into k pieces. A natural question arises here: …
منابع مشابه
Simultaneous Cake Cutting
We introduce the simultaneous model for cake cutting (the fair allocation of a divisible good), in which agents simultaneously send messages containing a sketch of their preferences over the cake. We show that this model enables the computation of divisions that satisfy proportionality — a popular fairness notion — using a protocol that circumvents a standard lower bound via parallel informatio...
متن کاملEnvy-free two-player mm-cake and three-player two-cake divisions
Cloutier, Nyman, and Su (Mathematical Social Sciences 59 (2005), 26–37) initiated the study of envy-free cake-cutting problems involving several cakes. The classical result in this area is that when there are q players and one cake, an envy-free cake-division requiring only q − 1 cuts exists under weak and natural assumptions. Among other results, Cloutier, Nyman, and Su showed that when there ...
متن کاملComputing socially-efficient cake divisions
We consider a setting in which a single divisible good (“cake”) needs to be divided between n players, each with a possibly different valuation function over pieces of the cake. For this setting, we address the problem of finding divisions that maximize the utilitarian social welfare, focusing on divisions where each player needs to get one contiguous piece of the cake. We provide a constant fa...
متن کاملEnvy-free cake divisions cannot be found by finite protocols
We show that no finite protocol (even if unbounded) can guarantee an envy-free division of a cake among three or more players, if each player is to receive a single connected piece.
متن کاملTwo-player envy-free multi-cake division
We introduce a generalized cake-cutting problem in which we seek to divide multiple cakes so that two players may get their most-preferred piece selections: a choice of one piece from each cake, allowing for the possibility of linked preferences over the cakes. For two players, we show that disjoint envy-free piece selections may not exist for two cakes cut into two pieces each, and they may no...
متن کامل